REDFLAG

Case file: Eddie Torreloma, NP

Practice locationArizona
Licensed statesAZ, KY, ME, SC
NPI1339611380
Back to Ask Red

Summary

The records show Eddie prescribing Schedule II stimulants, mostly by telehealth, to patients in four states where he has no license on record: New York, Rhode Island, Tennessee and Florida. Those prescriptions authorize refills, which federal law does not allow on Schedule II, and many are written above the labeled maximum daily dose. No DEA registration is on record for any of those patients’ states.

47Visits to patients in unlicensed states(of 282 total visits)
39Controlled prescriptions(Schedule II stimulants)
119Fills authorized(39 Rx, 1 to 3 refills each)
20Above labeled daily maximum(of the 39)
5Patients(reference codes only)
91%Telehealth(43 of the 47 visits)
4States with no license(NY, RI, FL, TN)
$4,003.13Paid on those 47 visits(Medicare and Medicare Advantage)

What the records show

Exhibit A
47

Prescribing into states with no license on record

47 visits and 39 controlled prescriptions for patients in NY, RI, TN and FL. His licenses on record are AZ, KY, ME and SC.

Exhibit B
119

Refills on Schedule II

39 of his 58 Schedule II prescriptions authorize 1 to 3 refills, 119 fills in all. Federal law does not allow refills on Schedule II. All 39 are the prescriptions written into the unlicensed states.

Exhibit B
20 of 39

Dose above the labeled maximum

20 of the 39 are written above the labeled maximum daily dose.

Exhibit C
0 of 39

No DEA registration for the patient’s state

None on record for any of the 39 prescriptions.

Which medications

Exhibit B

All five are Schedule II stimulants. Each bar splits into doses within and above the labeled maximum.

Lisdexamfetamine 30 mg12
Lisdexamfetamine 70 mg10
Methylphenidate 10 mg8
Methylphenidate 36 mg ER5
Dextroamphetamine-amphetamine 20 mg4

within labeled maximum above labeled maximum

Where he is licensed, and where he prescribed

Exhibit C

Licensed on record

✓ AZ✓ KY✓ ME✓ SC

Practice location: Arizona. Licenses as listed in the records, not checked with the boards.

No license on record 5 patients, 43 of 47 visits by telehealth

NY✗16 visits
RI✗12 visits
FL✗10 visits
TN✗9 visits

Sample claims: lisdexamfetamine 70 mg

Exhibit D
  • 10 prescriptions to 4 patients (NY, RI, TN, FL), 9 of them by telehealth, all on Schedule II.
  • Every prescription authorizes 1 to 3 refills, 32 fills in total.
  • 5 of the 10 are above the labeled maximum of 70 mg a day: 140 mg a day for the NY patient, 210 mg for the TN patient.
DateStatePatientDaily doseQtyRefillsFillsVisit typePaidClaim
2024-01-16RIP-3e31bf70 mg3023Video/phone$139.0638225306
2024-01-22TNP-58085d210 mg ▲9012In person$133.6414237ee0
2024-02-03NYP-5bf18b140 mg ▲6023Video/phone$175.66d8993784
2024-03-01RIP-3e31bf70 mg3023Video/phone$79.58724a3f01
2024-06-05TNP-58085d210 mg ▲9012Video/phone$13.467cc5d7dc
2024-07-07NYP-5bf18b140 mg ▲6034Video/phone$112.662903b517
2024-07-11RIP-3e31bf70 mg3034Video/phone$99.74c2c564f6
2024-09-28NYP-5bf18b140 mg ▲6023Video/phone$83.91867e3d73
2024-10-06RIP-3e31bf70 mg3034Video/phone$69.62c98ba9b6
2024-10-15FLP-851d7470 mg3034Video/phone$92.441bab1152
32$999.77

▲ above the labeled maximum of 70 mg a day. Patients are shown by reference code only. Claim shows the first 8 characters of the claim ID.

Estimated exposure for these claims

$999.77Paid by Medicare and Medicare Advantageon the 10 visit claims. Across all 47 visits: $4,003.13.

What it could grow into assumptions, not findings

Triple damages3 × the paid amount, the usual False Claims Act measure. A legal theory, not a finding.Legal theory$2,999.31
Civil penalties, ceiling10 claims × roughly $14,000 to $28,000 each. Adjusted every year; counsel must confirm.Legal theory$140,000 – $280,000
Drug cost to payersAbout 50 thirty-capsule fills at an estimated $100 (generic) to $450 (brand) per fill.Estimateabout $5,000 to $22,500

Evidence index

A
Visits and claims for patients in NY, RI, TN, FL

47 encounter and claim rows: service date, patient state, payer, paid amount, claim ID

See it in: Which states ›
B
The 39 controlled prescriptions

Medication request ID, drug, schedule, daily dose, labeled maximum, quantity, refills

See it in: Which medications ›
C
License and DEA registration

State licenses on record, prescriber DEA schedules, DEA registration in the patient’s state

See it in: License and DEA ›
D
Sample claims table

10 prescriptions and their 10 visit claims

See it in: Sample claims ›

Red flags for a criminal case

  1. 1

    No DEA registration for the patient’s state

    Exhibit C

    In the records. None on record for any of the 39 Schedule II prescriptions, written for patients in NY, RI, TN and FL.

    Why it matters. A practitioner needs DEA registration and state authority to prescribe controlled substances. Prescribing without them can be charged under the Controlled Substances Act on its own, whatever the medical merits (21 U.S.C. §§ 822 and 841(a)(1)).

  2. 2

    Refills on Schedule II

    Exhibit B

    In the records. All 39 prescriptions authorize 1 to 3 refills, 119 fills in all.

    Why it matters. Federal law bars refills on Schedule II (21 U.S.C. § 829(a)). It shows on the face of every prescription and needs no medical judgment to prove. Expect the defense that a system default added the refills.

  3. 3

    Doses above the labeled maximum

    Exhibit B

    In the records. 20 of the 39. The NY patient was prescribed 140 mg a day and the TN patient 210 mg, against a labeled maximum of 70 mg.

    Why it matters. The core test is whether a prescription was outside the usual course of professional practice or without a legitimate medical purpose (21 C.F.R. § 1306.04(a)). Doses far over the label are the evidence prosecutors use for that. Since Ruan v. United States (2022) they must also show he knew or intended it.

  4. 4

    No license in the patient’s state

    Exhibit A

    In the records. 47 visits, 43 by telehealth, to patients in NY, RI, TN and FL, where no license is on record. Medicare and Medicare Advantage paid $4,003.13.

    Why it matters. Practicing without a license is a state crime in many states. It also supports a health care fraud theory (18 U.S.C. § 1347) if the visits were billed as if lawful. The state boards must confirm his status.

  5. 5

    The same pattern, repeated for months

    Exhibit D

    In the records. 10 lisdexamfetamine 70 mg prescriptions to 4 patients between January and October 2024. The NY patient got 140 mg three times and the TN patient 210 mg twice, with no change.

    Why it matters. Repetition without correction is how prosecutors show knowledge instead of error, which Ruan requires. Pharmacy and prescription-monitoring records would show whether it continued.

Statute references are for orientation. Counsel confirms which charges fit, and the Department of Justice decides whether to bring them.